Tuesday, October 10, 2017

Potential Problems of Employee Engagement Programs


Employee Engagement can be a controversial topic mainly because it is hard to define and even harder to tie to business metrics and a quantifiable return on investment.
We often hear only the positives about employee engagement, and how it has become the Holy Grail within corporate America today.  In an article at ERE.net, John Sullivan PhD, an internationally known HR thought-leader, explored several insights into the problems concerning employee engagement programs.  If you want a better understanding of the pros and cons of this topic that seems to be on the top of most surveys that cover the concerns of the HR world today, you can download a copy of this paper here.  
Dr. Sullivan writes:

… there is far too little focus on the problems or issues related to engagement. … The process of gathering engagement data and the interpretation of it both improve dramatically when program managers and users are fully aware of all of its potential problems.”

Some of the employee engagement issues Dr. Sullivan gets into include:
  • That “engagement may be a byproduct, not a cause;
  • Engagement is not productivity or an output;
  • Outside factors influence engagement;
  • Diverse employees and different generations are engaged by different things;
  • Managers and employees don’t understand engagement;
  • The goals and metrics of engagement programs are often limited.
  • Engagement is not productivity or an output 
  • Engagement may be a byproduct not a cause;
  • High levels of engagement may not prohibit turnover
  • And many others 

The bottom line is; organizations are trying to manufacture engagement instead of figuring out what each employee's mind and heart are naturally engaged by.  It seems  the vast majority of organizations are afraid to ask, because they fear that it's not related to the business they're in.

For more information on Ultimate Choice Inc.’s products or services or other white papers please contact us at Ultimatechoiceinfo@cox.net